Asian Trips :: Black Garden: Armenia and Azerbaijan through Peace and War

Asian Trips - Black Garden: Armenia and Azerbaijan through Peace and War

Black Garden: Armenia and Azerbaijan through Peace and War
List Price: $22.00
www.asiantrips.info Price: $19.80
Your Save: $ 2.20 ( 10% )
Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours
Manufacturer: NYU Press
Average Customer Rating: Average rating of 4.0/5Average rating of 4.0/5Average rating of 4.0/5Average rating of 4.0/5Average rating of 4.0/5

Buy it now at Amazon.com!

Binding: Paperback
Dewey Decimal Number: 947.540854
EAN: 9780814719459
ISBN: 0814719457
Label: NYU Press
Manufacturer: NYU Press
Number Of Items: 1
Number Of Pages: 337
Publication Date: 2004-08-25
Publisher: NYU Press
Release Date: 2004-08-25
Studio: NYU Press

Related Items

Editorial Reviews:

"Brilliant."
Time

"This book is a major milestone in the Western scholarship on Karabakh."
Armenian Freedom Network

"Some of the most illuminating - and alarming - reading in de Waal's book includes the battle of historians and writers on both sides. They fire polemical missiles at each other through bscure history and literary journals, denigrating and, in some cases, obliterating the history and identity of the other side."
Eurasianet

"Only rarely does a university press publish such a gripping, poignant book as this. . . . This is an impressive work of careful scholarship and vivid writing."
Choice

"Admirable, rigorous. De Waal [is] a wise and patient reporter."
The New York Review

Black Garden is the definitive study of how Armenia and Azerbaijan, two southern Soviet republics, got sucked into a conflict that helped bring them to independence, bringing to an end the Soviet Union, and plaguing a region of great strategic importance. It cuts between a careful reconstruction of the history of Nagorny Karabakh conflict since 1988 and on-the-spot reporting on its convoluted aftermath.

Part contemporary history, part travel book, part political analysis, the book is based on six months traveling through the south Caucasus, more than 120 original interviews in the region, Moscow, and Washington, and unique primary sources, such as Politburo archives.

The historical chapters trace how the conflict lay unresolved in the Soviet era; how Armenian and Azerbaijani leaders exacerbated it; how the Politiboro failed to cope with the crisis; how the war began and ended; how the international community failed to sort out the conflict.

What emerges is a complex and subtle portrait of a beautiful and fascinating region, blighted by historical prejudice and conflict.




Spotlight customer reviews:

Customer Rating: Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5
Summary: Introduction to the Nagorny Karabakh Conundrum
Comment: After being introduced to the author's writing through a naïve-Westerner-written article titled "Abkhazia's Dream of Freedom" on Open Democracy's website, there was a good amount of skepticism when Black Garden was begun. Could Mr. deWaal write a book on the Nagorny Karabakh conflict and present both sides as equally and fairly as possible? Yes he could, and yes he has.

It is precisely this neutrality that gives Black Garden its strength. DeWaal's book is not a historical account but is deceptively similar. Black Garden blends history and extensive journalism--the culmination of his numerous forays into the Nagorny Karabakh Republic (NKR) statelet, Armenia and Azerbaijan--and presents a delicately balanced look at the frozen post-Soviet conflict. Thoroughly researched and deeply studied by the author, a journalist and not a historian, the full but obscure history of this little-known conflict is brought to light and common misconceptions are debunked. Nagorny Karabakh was not about ancient hatreds; for one, it was and remains the result of callous Soviet policies that could never have lasted without a constant and brutal overlord-state to maintain them.

Black Garden does well as a one-stop overall introduction to the NKR conflict. From here, readers can at least have some background with which to pursue further study, be it from the Armenian perspective or the Azeri. It would have been easy for the author to take a side. The fact that he didn't is what makes Black Garden a solid foundation for learning about the Nagorny Karabakh conundrum.


Customer Rating: Average rating of 3/5Average rating of 3/5Average rating of 3/5Average rating of 3/5Average rating of 3/5
Summary: Good book to inform but stumbles from an intricate balancing act
Comment: Thomas De Waal's book "Black Garden" is one of the first publications that has been a written by an unbiased source on the Armenian-Azeri, Nagorno-Karabakh conflict that began in the latter of half of the 20th century, just as the Soviet Union gave way to form 15 independent republics. In the ensuing introduction of perestroika and glasnost by Mikhail Gorbachev from 1985 onwards, Armenians decided to take advantage and push and take back Karabakh, peacefully at first and violently when war crept forward from the horizon. De Waal does an interesting job in interviewing both Armenian and Azeri officials and those who (mis)lead their respective countries. The Azerbaijani government's numerous coups severly hindered their efforts to focus on the region, rather than the country as a whole. De Waal also dwells into the beginnings and history of the region and consequently debunks myths that were propagated by both sides.

However, it is in this where his book is mired with frustration and displaced onto the reader, a key factor of De Waal's undoing. He unfortunately concentrates too much of his time giving both sides 50-50 air time to explore controverserial issues. For example, when speaking about the 1915 Armenian Genocide and sympathizing for the victims and attending the march in Yerevan, De Waal brings up the recent Azeris' new claims that a genocide had been perpetrated against them by Armenians; giving equality for both without elaborating enough that the Azeris' claims are largely unfounded. He also makes unconvincingly generaliztions: he states that during the Karabakh protests outside Yerevan in February 1988, some Armenians didn't even know where the region was and had simply decided to skip work that day. He also has reluctance to condemn either side of wrongdoing. Near the end of his book, he states that Armenians felt the issue began in Sumgait, Azerbaijan (the site of a brutal pogrom of Armenians by Azeris) while the Azeris said it began in Khojaly in 1992 (the site of an alleged mass murder of Azeris by Armenian armed forces) and finally, leaves the reader hanging on on the edge of a cliff, not dwelling or at the very least expressing his opinion on it; a habit that is otherwise prevalent in his book. Some of the sources he uses are also rather unreliable, whether they come from interviews by former Armenian, Russian, or Azeri leaders or from writers who had slant towards either side (Andrei Sakharov, Thomas Goltz). His book also substantially covers many pages of Karabakh's history. From the reign of the Armenian Meliks (princes) in the 12-13th centuries who governed Karabakh to the protests in Yerevan and Baku (Armenia and Azerbaijan's capitals, respectfully) in 1988 to the peace talks in Key West, Florida in the summer of 2001.

Another shortcoming is in De Waal's subtle yet central theme, in that of his constant promulgation that Armenians and Azeris are largely alike and had a good relationship with each other until the conflict began in 1988. I lived in Armenia and have spoken to many Armenians and for the most part, Armenians did not have any extraordinary friendships with them. Perhaps this is true in Baku, Karabakh, or Sumgait but I felt that De Waal inflated this claim in an appreciated effort to mollify both sides in seeking a peaceful solution to the conflict. De Waal makes little effort to emphasize of how a brutally dishonest and racist campaign is undertaken by the Azeri government to this day to smear and criticze Armenians; going so far as equate them to the Nazis and even discredit the history of their existance. His analogies are also lopsided; he rightly castigates the work of the Azeri "historian" Ziya Buniatov for blatant academic dishonesty but then compares his actions to the Glasnost-era Armenian writer Zori Balayan who correctly asserted that Azeris had Turkic heritage. Later on in the book, while he again criticizes the harsh rule Armenians lived under the Azeris, he quickly goes on and (inaccurately) condemns Armenians for enacting the same brutal deeds during the 20th century against the Azeris. Perhaps the most contemptible and unconvincing example that he uses is in the end chapter of the book. De Waal praises the famous 18th century Armenian poet Sayat Nova who supposedly overcame the divide and made peace between not only the Armenians and Azeris, but also the Caucasian Georgians. De Waal admonishes both sides for not taking Nova's example but leaves out the brutal circumstances of his death. In 1795, the invading Iranians, led by the Azeri Prince Agha Mohammed Khan, demanded that Sayat Nova convert to Islam. Nova was a Christian and refused to do so and hence, was promptly executed and beheaded.

Nevertheless, it is a welcoming gesture to bridge the divide between two peoples as. In either case, De Waal should be commended for writing the book and my own misgivings shouldn't preclude someone from reading it.

Customer Rating: Average rating of 4/5Average rating of 4/5Average rating of 4/5Average rating of 4/5Average rating of 4/5
Summary: Black Garden: Armenia and Azerbaijan through Peace and War
Comment: Black Garden is an unbiased look at the conflict between the two Cacusus nations, which chronicles the conflict from the first shot to the the current uneasy truce. It is a great read for anyone interested in the region it's peoples culture and recent history.

Customer Rating: Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5
Summary: Recommended
Comment: I defitely recommend buyig this book: it offers tons of information on the Caucasus region and is easy to read.

Customer Rating: Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5Average rating of 5/5
Summary: An excellent book
Comment: Tons of information, easy to read, thorough analysis, reference to the reliable third-party facts.


Buy it now at Amazon.com!


Asia Posters
Asia Art Prints
Asia Travel 2008 Calendars
2008 Monthly Calendars


Asia Trips Important Resources
Asia Trips Books
Asia Trips DVD
Asia Trips Softwares
Asia Trips Magazines


Asia Trips Special Resources
Asia Arts
Asia Entertainment
Asia Business
Asia Culture
Asia Education
Asia Government
Asia Health
Asia Map
Asia Attractions
Asia Beach
Asia Festivals

Asia Hotels
Asia Museums
Theme Parks
Transportation

Foods and Recipes
Sports & Recreation
Travel & Tourism


Asian Trips Destinations
Afghanistan
Armenia
Azerbaijan
Bangladesh
Bhutan
Brunei
Cambodia
China
Georgia
HongKong
India
Indonesia
Japan
Kazakhstan
Kyrgyzstan
Laos
Macau
Malaysia
Maldives
Mongolia
Myanmar
Nepal
NorthKorea
Pakistan
Philippines
Singapore
SouthKorea
SriLanka
Taiwan
Tajikistan
Thailand
Tibet
Turkmenistan
Uzbekistan
Vietnam



Asia Trips
Maintained by: Marketer Solutions | Link Building